Vehicle GPS vs. phone GPS for landscape crews
Vehicle GPS shows where a landscape crew’s truck went and how long it stayed; phone GPS shows where each crew member went on the property and how long each part of the work took.
Most landscape companies that track anything track trucks. That answers routing questions well and on-site questions not at all.
| Vehicle GPS | Phone GPS | |
|---|---|---|
| Tracks | The truck | Each crew member |
| Arrival and departure | Yes | Yes |
| Windshield time and routes | Yes | Yes |
| Time per zone and task on site | No | Yes |
| Walking, waiting, refueling | No | Yes |
| Hardware | Installed tracker | Phones crews already carry |
| Depends on | Power to the tracker | Phone carried, app running, battery |
When vehicle GPS is enough
If the questions are about routes, such as which stops are far apart, how long drives take, or whether a truck went somewhere it shouldn’t, vehicle GPS answers them with no effort from the crew.
When you need phone GPS
If the question is why a property takes 3h 40m when it should take 3h, the truck can’t tell you; it sat in one spot the whole visit. Per-person, per-zone time needs a location source that walks with the worker. That is what a GPS time study uses.
What to settle before tracking phones
- Tell the crews. Workers should know the app is tracking, during which hours, and how to stop it. Notice and consent rules vary by state.
- Battery. A location app running all day uses battery; a charger in the truck covers it.
- Company or personal phones. Either works; tracking a personal phone needs clearer boundaries on hours.
Motion Map uses GPS from crew members’ phones. It needs no new hardware, and it works beside the vehicle tracking you may already run.
Questions
Can vehicle GPS measure time per task?
Vehicle GPS cannot measure time per task, because the truck usually stays parked while the crew works. It measures arrival, departure and driving.
Do crew members need company phones for phone GPS tracking?
Phone GPS tracking works on company or personal phones. With personal phones, limit tracking to work hours and make sure crews know when it is on.